Dark Guilds

I say out with TarTarus...

and in with GH.

http://fairytail.wikia.com/wiki/Grimoire_Heart

Also I might take ... http://fairytail.wikia.com/wiki/Blue_Skull

Just thinking outloud

Why not keep Tartarus and add the GH one as well? o.0

That's a lot of guilds...

But I also don't recommend the whole "GM gets _ Rank"

That's stupid... but some peeps should start a higher rank to start of the site... er kick it off.

Spinal Tap wrote:That's a lot of guilds...

But I also don't recommend the whole "GM gets _ Rank"

That's stupid... but some peeps should start a higher rank to start of the site... er kick it off.

Thing is, GM's are supposedly the strongest mages within a guild. Why not just give them __ rank and have them work their way up? It's allowing them obtain the spell slots up to S, but if they dont gain XP and they lose their spot, they go back down to their original rank 0.o

Because that was FTRP's backdraw.

I say give them a boost... but only for starting members. Like if I just bought a guild, IC why would I jump 7 ranks?

Serenity wrote:

Spinal Tap wrote:That's a lot of guilds...

But I also don't recommend the whole "GM gets _ Rank"

That's stupid... but some peeps should start a higher rank to start of the site... er kick it off.

Thing is, GM's are supposedly the strongest mages within a guild. Why not just give them __ rank and have them work their way up? It's allowing them obtain the spell slots up to S, but if they dont gain XP and they lose their spot, they go back down to their original rank 0.o

I'd have to agree with this. Having a GM be no stronger than the average member would contradict their being the guild's leader. Kind of common knowledge that you aren't going to work under someone if they aren't as strong as, or stronger than you are. As for their having to gain Exp, I support this. Though, I think we should think up a special method for GM's to gain Exp.

You don't magically get the amount of money to obtain a guild. You have to work for it. So those who buy a guild would have either done a bunch of jobs for one or have a group of people support him/her to obtain the guild and with it the perks 0.o

Spinal Tap wrote:Because that was FTRP's backdraw.

I say give them a boost... but only for starting members. Like if I just bought a guild, IC why would I jump 7 ranks?

Yeah. If you buy a Guild IC, you should still have to work you way up to the actual GM rank.

I say give a boost...

Like a few ranks upon their own.

Because as it stands... You could get the points with one acc, and buy the guild for the other.

*Ahem*LikeZenneth*Ahem*

hmmm....

Sora wrote:

Spinal Tap wrote:Because that was FTRP's backdraw.

I say give them a boost... but only for starting members. Like if I just bought a guild, IC why would I jump 7 ranks?

Yeah. If you buy a Guild IC, you should still have to work you way up to the actual GM rank.

Serenity wrote:You don't magically get the amount of money to obtain a guild. You have to work for it. So those who buy a guild would have either done a bunch of jobs for one or have a group of people support him/her to obtain the guild and with it the perks 0.o

So... also incorporate that they must be of a certain rank so that they can obtain a guild? Like you have to be an A or B rank with the amount of money to buy a guild? 0.o

Well, I'm assuming we're doing EXP.

So why not just give a +1,000 EXP with a guild.

No more, no less... or whatever number.

So like the Keyblades system in ulrp?

Admin wrote:So like the Keyblades system in ulrp?

Like that... in a dumbed down version.. I guess...

but not like F > A... Just like a 1,000.

Because like you said... if they really WORKED for that money... they should be a higher rank anyways,

Serenity wrote:hmmm....

Sora wrote:

Spinal Tap wrote:Because that was FTRP's backdraw.

I say give them a boost... but only for starting members. Like if I just bought a guild, IC why would I jump 7 ranks?

Yeah. If you buy a Guild IC, you should still have to work you way up to the actual GM rank.

Serenity wrote:You don't magically get the amount of money to obtain a guild. You have to work for it. So those who buy a guild would have either done a bunch of jobs for one or have a group of people support him/her to obtain the guild and with it the perks 0.o

So... also incorporate that they must be of a certain rank so that they can obtain a guild? Like you have to be an A or B rank with the amount of money to buy a guild?  0.o

I think having to be A-rank and have the necessary amount of money to actually buy the guild is a good idea.

Sora wrote:

Serenity wrote:hmmm....

Sora wrote:

Spinal Tap wrote:Because that was FTRP's backdraw.

I say give them a boost... but only for starting members. Like if I just bought a guild, IC why would I jump 7 ranks?

Yeah. If you buy a Guild IC, you should still have to work you way up to the actual GM rank.

Serenity wrote:You don't magically get the amount of money to obtain a guild. You have to work for it. So those who buy a guild would have either done a bunch of jobs for one or have a group of people support him/her to obtain the guild and with it the perks 0.o

So... also incorporate that they must be of a certain rank so that they can obtain a guild? Like you have to be an A or B rank with the amount of money to buy a guild?  0.o

I think having to be A-rank and have the necessary amount of money to actually buy the guild is a good idea.

Spinal Tap wrote:

Admin wrote:So like the Keyblades system in ulrp?

Like that... in a dumbed down version.. I guess...

but not like F > A... Just like a 1,000.

Because like you said... if they really WORKED for that money... they should be a higher rank anyways,

Let me get this right... So, excluding the guilds we have right now, if members buy a guild, then they have to be of at least A rank along with having the necessary money. Once they complete the requirements, they get 'jumped' to this ___ rank where, if they lose their position as GM, they go back to the rank they normally were? Whereas those who get guilds that were created now, will be jumped to the ___ rank?

What I see wrong with not having the ___ rank system is that GM are the strongest of their respective guilds. They display power and rank. Reason why people follow them and o not dare disobey them. Not applying it and simply giving them the XP will make them simply an ordinary mage and not give the power that the GM are supposedly supposed to wield. It's not giving them an automatic rank but simply having them work for it or they risk going back to the original rank they were if the GM rank would be to be revoked 0.o

On another note, Sora came up with the idea.. we'll be keeping independent guilds but capping it, for now, at two unless stated otherwise. That way they exist yet are not abused. If someone reeeeeeally wants to make a third neutral guild for whatever reason, they could submit an appeal of some sort and we could negotiate it thataway 0.o

TL;DR

We're keeping Neutral Guilds because Sora said so.
I still stand by the "Keyblade EXP" concept to boost them.
I still say no starting neutral guilds, HOWEVER,later on... yes.

People starting as GM's right now should get the boost... but say... the "Zenneth Effect" where someone passes down GM position... i, in no way, will every see how it makes sense to have someone jump instantly to S rank just because of a "Title"

People who start guilds, HELL YES. People who inherit the guild master title? No.

I see, so you're suggesting that if you pass down the title, they get the XP boost (keyblades master effect) but nothing else? While as the first GM's get the ___ "boost?"

Serenity wrote:I see, so you're suggesting that if you pass down the title, they get the XP boost (keyblades master effect) but nothing else? While as the first GM's get the ___ "boost?"

Correct.

Meaning everyone is Sonya, but afterwards everyone new is Fetus.

Ah okays. Sounds good to me :3